Still no justice for ‘defenceless’ Stockton widow, Thirty-seven years after her brutal murder

The brutal murder of 94-year-old Kate Simpson in her Hartburn home remains one of Cleveland Police’s most haunting cold cases. Despite extensive investigations and the conviction of three teenagers—later overturned—no one has been definitively held accountable for the crime. Even after nearly 37 years, authorities remain open to new leads and continue seeking justice for the well-respected widow.

A Shocking Crime in a Quiet Neighborhood

On February 27, 1988, Kate Simpson, a friendly and independent elderly woman, was tragically murdered in her Hartburn Avenue home near Ropner Park. Known for her kindness and self-sufficiency, Mrs. Simpson had lived alone since the passing of her husband, a British Rail executive, two decades earlier.

Her final known contact was a 9:45 AM phone call to her best friend, giving her a shopping list. By 3:00 PM, the same friend arrived with groceries and found the front door open—a chilling sign of what had transpired. Inside, she discovered Mrs. Simpson’s lifeless body on the living room floor, a kitchen carving knife plunged into her chest. The attack had severed her aorta, and she also bore facial bruising and neck injuries, suggesting a violent struggle.

The Extensive Investigation

The murder of a defenseless 94-year-old woman prompted Cleveland Police to launch what was then their biggest investigation in 15 years. The efforts included:

• 1,707 lines of inquiry pursued.
• 1,093 statements taken from potential witnesses.
• 1,200 house-to-house visits conducted.
• Over 2,000 vehicles stopped in roadblocks near the crime scene.

Detective Chief Inspector Ron Newsam, who led the investigation, described the attack as “callous and totally unnecessary.” He emphasized that Mrs. Simpson was a gentle, well-loved woman without enemies.

One of the first detectives on the scene, Detective Inspector Dave Scott, recalled his overwhelming sorrow and anger upon witnessing the brutal crime. He described how the police force felt a deep personal commitment to solving the case.

Wrongful Convictions and an Ongoing Mystery

Just two weeks after the murder, three local teenagers were arrested and charged. They were convicted in court:

• Two were sentenced to life for murder.
• One was sentenced for manslaughter.

However, in 1992, their convictions were overturned by the Court of Appeal due to insufficient evidence and concerns about the fairness of the trial. Following their release, authorities initially declined to reopen the case, leaving Mrs. Simpson’s true killers unidentified.

Cold Case Review and New Theories

In 2019, Cleveland Police revisited the case, proposing a new theory:

• The killers were likely “artifice burglars”, also known as distraction burglars, who trick elderly victims to gain access to their homes.
• There were likely at least two attackers involved.
• Some of those present may not have intended for the crime to end in murder.

Despite the passage of time, police remained open to new information, urging anyone with knowledge to come forward.

A Case Still Seeking Justice

Even after 37 years, the brutal killing of Kate Simpson remains an open wound for her community and family. Cleveland Police have reaffirmed their commitment to investigating any new leads and encourage potential witnesses to come forward.

With advancements in forensic science and renewed public interest in cold cases, there remains hope that justice may finally be served for a woman who deserved a peaceful life.

SOURCE