Five years ago, a young life was cut short in a brutal act of violence that shattered a family forever. Taylor Black, an 18-year-old university student from Stockton, was stabbed 64 times by someone he once considered a friend. As his mother, Lindsey Allison, marks this painful anniversary, she reflects on the immense loss, the trauma her family has endured, and the strength she finds in her younger son, Shae.
The Night That Changed Everything
On February 17, 2020, Taylor Black went to a birthday party, never to return home. He was found brutally stabbed, with 40 of the wounds inflicted on his head. His attacker, Nathan Costello, had been a friend through their shared interest in martial arts. Despite confessing to the crime in text messages, Costello later pleaded not guilty in court, claiming he had no memory of the attack.
The trial brought unimaginable pain to Taylor’s family, as they had to listen to the horrific details of his murder. For Lindsey, this was just the beginning of a long, heartbreaking journey.
A Double Tragedy: Losing a Brother Too
As Lindsey tried to cope with the loss of her son, another devastating blow struck her family. During the trial, her brother Niki, who was deeply affected by the details of Taylor’s murder, took his own life. Lindsey discovered his body in her shed—a moment she describes as soul-crushing.
“My son’s killer took two lives when he decided to butcher my son,” Lindsey said. “He took my brother’s life too.”
The family was left to bury not only Taylor but also Niki, compounding their grief. Lindsey often questions what she did to deserve such overwhelming sorrow.
The Ongoing Struggles of a Grieving Family
Lindsey admits that life has never been the same since losing Taylor. The carefree person she once was is gone, replaced by someone who has learned to live with constant pain. Her younger son, Shae, now struggles with severe separation anxiety, fearing that he might lose his mother too.
“My little boy, Shae, is what keeps me going,” Lindsey shares. “Every day is a struggle, but when I see his innocent face and his smile, it gives me the strength to carry on.”
Her mother has also been diagnosed with PTSD, haunted by the tragic loss of her grandson. The family’s mental health battles are a constant reminder of the violence that tore their lives apart.
Seeking Justice and Closure
Nathan Costello was eventually convicted of Taylor’s murder and sentenced to life imprisonment with a minimum of 21 years. While justice was served, it did little to ease the pain for Lindsey and her family.
“The verdict gave us some closure,” Lindsey said, “but it will never bring Taylor back. The future he could have had was stolen from him.”
Finding Strength in Love and Hope
Despite the immense grief, Lindsey remains determined to give Shae a happy childhood. She knows that Taylor would want his little brother to experience joy and laughter, just as he once did.
“I grieve the future Taylor will never have,” she says, “but I also find hope knowing that one day, when my time is up, his face will be the first one I see.”
Lindsey holds on to the belief that Taylor is watching over them, and she continues to fight every day to honor his memory.
The past five years have been a long, painful journey for Lindsey Allison and her family. The tragic loss of her son Taylor, followed by the heartbreaking death of her brother Niki, left wounds that may never fully heal. Yet, through her pain, Lindsey continues to find strength in her love for Shae and her cherished memories of Taylor.
| Visit for More News and Updates | WSOA NEWS |
