Fans Think April Is Lying About Her Baby’s Father—Here’s Why

Updated On:
Fans Think April Is Lying About Her Baby’s Father—Here’s Why

Emmerdale viewers have been left heartbroken after April Windsor tragically suffered a stillbirth earlier in the week. The devastating storyline unfolded after April ran away from home, struggling to come to terms with her pregnancy and fearing how it would affect her family.

April’s Emotional Confession to Marlon

April had been keeping her pregnancy a secret from her father, Marlon Dingle, and stepmother, Rhona Goskirk. She admitted she felt invisible in the family, especially with the focus on Leo, Marlon’s stroke recovery, and the tension over Ivy nearly breaking up her parents.

In an emotional confrontation with her father, April revealed why she had kept everything from him:

“I wanted to tell you, I almost did. But then, I found out that you’d always known how my mum really died. Lied to me about it my whole life. So then I figured, if you could keep secrets then so could I. You hardly ever noticed me unless I was drunk.”

Her heartbreaking words showed just how much she had been struggling, feeling like she had to be the strong one while her family faced their own challenges.

Who Is the Father of April’s Baby?

Since the episode aired, fans have been speculating about the identity of the father. April told Marlon that the father was “a random lad she met at a party” and that she “didn’t even know his name”. However, many viewers aren’t convinced she is telling the truth.

Reddit Theories on the Baby’s Father

One fan analyzed the timeline of her pregnancy, suggesting:

“It was a fully formed (premature) baby, so she was probably at least five months pregnant, meaning she likely conceived around August or September. I don’t think there was much focus on her storyline at that point, so really, it could be anyone—but most likely, I think it’ll be a new character.”

Another viewer offered a different perspective, believing the mystery is intentional:

“I think they never told the viewer so we would be in the same position as Marlon—completely in the dark, trust shaken, and no information. Many parents go through this moment, not knowing everything about their child’s life. It’s even harder now with the Internet, where anyone can contact anyone.”

Some fans had previously suspected Anthony Fox, but based on the pregnancy timeline, many are ruling him out as the father.

Is April Hiding the Truth?

While April insists that she doesn’t know the identity of the father, some fans believe she is protecting someone. Could there be a bigger twist ahead? Given Emmerdale’s history of shocking reveals, viewers are eagerly awaiting more clues.

Support for Those Affected

April’s devastating storyline highlights the emotional impact of stillbirth, a tragic experience that many families face. If you or someone you know has been affected by a similar situation, support is available through Sands (Stillbirth and Neonatal Death Charity).

Call Sands on 0808 164 3332
Email [email protected]

SOURCE

Leave a Comment